The best Mystery Games on PC are a great choice for puzzle fans who also like detailed detective stories. Fans can finally be a part of their favorite stories and solve the most twisted and complicated crimes in gaming history thanks to these often immersive games. Players can go after dangerous murderers, be private detectives, or even be renegade cops who make up their own rules in these games. Below we mentioned the best Mystery Games on PC.
Best Mystery Games on PC Comparison Table
| Game | Genre | Mode | Price | Download Game |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| We Were Here Too | Puzzle, Co-op | Multiplayer | $9.99 | Download Game |
| Roman’s Christmas | Adventure | Single-player | $6.99 | Download Game |
| Project Kat Paper Lily Prologue | Visual Novel | Single-player | Free | Download Game |
| The Rewinder | Adventure | Single-player | $19.99 | Download Game |
| L.A. Noire | Action-Adventure, Detective | Single-player | $39.99 | Download Game |
| The Wolf Among Us | Adventure | Single-player | $14.99 | Download Game |
We Were Here Too
Features
- Cooperative puzzle-solving,
- unique challenges,
- atmospheric environments.
We Were Here Too is one of the most complicated PC mystery games. It takes place in a beautiful and spooky medieval castle. This fantasy-inspired co-op mystery game is perfect for people who like challenging brain teasers and solving puzzles. Currently, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
But players will need to not only use their problem-solving skills and creativity, but also improve their ability to talk to each other and work as a team, if they want to solve the old mysteries of the castle and get out alive. As players explore the castle and talk to each other through their walkie-talkies, they will have to make tough choices and solve creative puzzles. It’s one of the most atmospheric mystery games, and both new and experienced players will enjoy it.
Pros
- Unique co-op puzzle gameplay,
- good communication practice.
Cons
- Short playtime,
- limited replayability.
Roman’s Christmas
Features
- Point-and-click adventure,
- charming hand-drawn art,
- holiday-themed.
Roman’s Christmas is one of the best-rated mystery PC games of all time. It has a charming art style that is inspired by fantasy, fun characters with fur, and mysteries that are much darker than you might expect. This dark visual novel mystery game has a fun story about a wolf detective named Roman who wants to spend a quiet Christmas at his tavern but can’t because of all the murders.
It’s perfect for people who like classic noir mystery games and want a new one with a story that’s good for LGBTQ+ people. Players will have to use their detective skills and put themselves in Roman’s shoes to find out who killed the man. They will do this by looking at the evidence, going through all of the tavern’s rooms, talking to the other guests, and, of course, using Roman’s unique ability to smell. Still, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
Pros
- Atmospheric and nostalgic
- engaging puzzles.
Cons
- Short playtime,
- limited replayability.
Project Kat – Paper Lily Prologue
Features
- Emotional story,
- stunning visuals,
- immersive soundtrack.
One of the most popular psychological horror RPGs of all time, Project Kat: Paper Lily Prologue has a dark and twisty mystery. It’s a pretty short game, but it’s a lot of fun, and there are different endings that depend on what the players do. Thus, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
It’s one of the scariest and funniest mystery PC games. A few chosen characters get a mysterious golden letter, and players have to figure out what’s inside. In this fun, spooky mystery game, players get to explore a creepy school after dark, solving puzzles, playing minigames, and making new friends and enemies along the way.
Pros
- Engaging narrative,
- stunning artwork,
- immersive worldbuilding.
Cons
- Short playtime,
- limited interactivity.
The Rewinder
Features
- Time travel,
- moral choices,
- gorgeous hand-painted artwork.
One of the most interesting new mystery PC games, The Rewinder, was inspired by Chinese art and mythology. It has hauntingly beautiful pixel graphics that were inspired by Chinese ink paintings, and its twisty mystery story was based on old Chinese myths. Players get to go on a scary puzzle adventure as Yun, the last known Rewinder, who is a supernatural detective.
Yun must go to a small village in China to find out what happened there seven years ago. The strange thing that happened turned the once-bustling village into a haunted place full of angry ghosts. If players want to solve the dark mystery, they will have to use Yun’s special supernatural skills and talk to the ghosts. Currently, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
Pros
- Engaging storytelling,
- beautiful artwork.
Cons
- Short playtime,
- limited interactivity.
L.A. Noire
Features
- Open-world investigation,
- interrogations,
- realistic 1940s Los Angeles.
This detective action game based on film noir is great for people who like classic mysteries. It’s an interactive story that takes place in 1947 in Los Angeles. It’s one of the best immersive open-world games set in history, and players take on the role of Cole Phelps, an L.A. cop. In this moody game, players have to solve crimes, including brutal serial murders, by questioning suspects, going to crime scenes, and, of course, finding and figuring out all the clues.
L.A. Noire is also a great choice for casual gamers and newcomers because it is not only one of the best games of its kind but also lets players skip parts they find too hard. This makes the game much more fun for all types of gamers. Still, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
Pros
- Immersive story,
- realistic graphics,
- engaging gameplay mechanics.
Cons
- Some repetitive gameplay,
- not all cases are equally engaging.
The Wolf Among Us
Features
- Choice-driven narrative,
- branching storylines,
- gritty fairytale setting.
The Wolf Among Us is an episode-based graphic mystery game that is based on the popular Fables comic book series. It is one of the best games for people who like true crime and twisted fairy tales. In this beautiful-looking game, fairytale characters are being killed, and players take control of the main character, Detective Bigby, also known as the Big Bad Wolf and the sheriff of Fabletown.
Even though the game is based on characters from fairy tales, it is still a mature thriller with some pretty brutal murders. In this game, the investigation is not as in-depth, but every choice the player makes has a big effect on how the story ends. Overall, this is one of the Best Mystery Games on PC.
Pros
- Engaging story,
- great voice acting,
- immersive worldbuilding.
Cons
- Some repetitive gameplay,
- can feel slow-paced at times.
What is a PC game where you play a detective?
Broken Sword. The Wolf Among Us. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter. Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments.
What PC games are like bookworm?
The best alternative is Falling Word Search, which is free. Other Bookworm (by PopCap) like games are Tanglet, Lexica, Word Wise and Alphabear.
FAQs
What PC games are like Pocket Legends?
It’s not free, so you could try Runescape or Black Desert Online if you want something free. Aion, EverQuest, Wizard101, and Inotia 3: Children of Carnia are all games that are similar to Pocket Legends. Most of the games that are like Pocket Legends are Role-Playing Games, but some of them are also MMORPG Games or Adventure Games.
Is there a game like true crime?
Players take control of police officer Cole Phelps in the middle of a very accurate L.A., where they have to solve crimes and fight people to become better detectives.
