Judge Drops Murder Charge Against Philadelphia Police Officer in Fatal Traffic Stop Shooting

Judge drops murder charge against Philadelphia police officer who shot driver during traffic stop

A judge on Tuesday dismissed all charges, including murder, against the Philadelphia police officer who had been accused of wrongfully killing a motorist last month.

Mark Dial pulled over Eddie Irizarry, 27, on Aug. 14 before he shot him through the rolled-up driver’s side window, body camera video has shown.

The defense argued that Dial, 27, could be seen backing away from the vehicle as he opened fire, believing Irizarry had a gun. The video showed that Irizarry had been holding a knife in his right hand.

Dial had been charged with murder, voluntary manslaughter, official oppression and four other counts before Pew dismissed all counts.

Prosecutors vowed to appeal Pew’s ruling and have charges brought against Dial again.

Insufficient evidence leads to dismissal of charges

The video was played in court Tuesday, but Philadelphia Municipal Judge Wendy Pew ruled there was not enough evidence to go to trial, bringing an emotional reaction from Irizarry’s loved ones in court.

Defense argues self-defense

The defense argued that Dial believed Irizarry had a gun and could be seen backing away from the vehicle as he opened fire. The video showed that Irizarry had been holding a knife in his right hand, supporting the defense’s claim of self-defense.

Prosecutors vow to appeal

Despite the dismissal of charges, prosecutors have vowed to appeal the ruling and bring charges against Dial again. The District Attorney’s Office disagrees with the decision and will seek to reinstate all criminal charges, including murder.

Source Credit